Skip to Content

Deviled Egg Bloody Eyeballs

These Deviled Egg Bloody Eyeballs are naturally colored and made with only a handful of ingredients – and these sure would make one bloody awesome Halloween appetizer!

Deviled Egg Bloody Eyeballs - Deviled eggs loose the mayo and gain a bit of healthy in these bloody beety eyeballs!

Happy Halloween Y’all! This year has zoomed by so fast that I’m having a hard time wrapping my head around the fact that today is actually October 31st; the fact that it is 85 degrees here in Hotlanta doesn’t help either! I’m hoping you have all sorts of ghoulish parties to attend or trick or treating to do – as for my daughter and I, why we are camping out in front of the telly armed with scary movies and creepy snacks like these Bloody Eyeballs! I first made these eyeballs for my daughter last year when she decided to forgo our Halloween trick or treating shenanigans in favor of scary movies and creepy snacks at home…and I had couldn’t help reminiscing…

Deviled Egg Bloody Eyeballs - Deviled eggs loose the mayo and gain a bit of healthy in these bloody beety eyeballs!

In the neighborhood I used to take my daughter trick-or-treating in, just about every house went all out. There was this one house that had scary music playing and smoke filling the yard and if you were brave enough to walk up to the door and ring the bell, you were greeted by Mr. and Mrs. Frankenstein! Then there was this other house that had a haunted house – in their front yard! Trick or treaters would be so spooked by that haunted house that most times they’d run out of it and run off, completely forgetting to collect their “treats” in the process! There was yet another house that had a graveyard in their front yard – and… scattered among the plethora of R.I.P. gravestones were battery operated creepy crawlies, hands coming out of the ground and people popping out of their graves!

Deviled Egg Bloody Eyeballs - Deviled eggs loose the mayo and gain a bit of healthy in these bloody beety eyeballs!

But, from all these houses, my favorite one was the one that had a buffet laid out. On one side of their garage, these foodie-folks would have a table set out with every kind of candy imaginable for the kids to help themselves to and on the other side of their garage, they had a table set up for the parents who were braving the night. And boy-oh-boy did they go all out! One year there was chili with hot dogs and cornbread. Then another year they were grilling chicken and you could have your pick of coleslaw or potato wedges. And then there was this other time when they had their table decked out with a smorgasbord of Halloween appetizers like asparagus and bacon mummies, mummies-in-a-blanket, meatball and chip bats, a skull cheese-ball with witch fingers to dip into it with, and bloody deviled eggs made devilish with ketchup and mustard.

Yes – it was their bloody deviled eggs that inspired these Deviled Egg Bloody Eyeballs. However, I did not use ketchup and food coloring like they did. I also skipped on the mayo that goes into most deviled eggs. What I did use for the coloring were beets, which- when mixed with spicy mustard and paprika, made for a deviled egg even my traditional-deviled-egg-obsessed teen daughter approved of! While these might not be the prettiest deviled eggs around, they sure are a heck of a tasty, healthy alternative!

This recipe first appeared on FoodFanatic – for more recipes like this or more recipe ideas and inspiration, please visit FoodFanatic.com

label


Want something sweet after? The How about these Bloody Beet Bowls (with edible bowls and spoons)?

Bloody Beet Bowls With Chocoley White Chocolate & Beets
Date And Banana Muffins with Cacao Nibs (Refined Sugar-Free and Gluten-free)
← Previous
Pumpkin Spice, Almond & Raspberry Hot Chocolates
Next →

Beet Deviled Eggs Recipe - Savory Spin

Monday 25th of November 2019

[…] few years ago, I made these Deviled Egg Bloody (beet) Eyeballs. This year, I am sticking with the beet theme, only jazzing it up in a different way. Like they did […]

Beet Deviled Eggs

Monday 5th of November 2018

[…] few years ago, I made these Deviled Egg Bloody (beet) Eyeballs. This year, I am sticking with the beet theme, only jazzing it up in a different way. Like they did […]

Ghoulishly Good! Halloween Party Recipes and Ideas - Vintage Kitty

Saturday 8th of September 2018

[…] Rough night? Or did you have a bloody good time?  Check out this twist on deviled eggs from Savory Spin. […]

Gala in the kitchen

Tuesday 30th of January 2018

So creative idea for Halloween! Love recipe, no artificial food coloring!

Ala

Tuesday 1st of November 2016

WHAT. Seriously, Shashi, I've been scouring through my fair share of Halloween-themed treats and these are some of the most creative! I love this idea so much--only 364 days to go until I can make them! xo