Cinnamon Oatmeal Ice Cream
This post featuring Cinnamon Oatmeal Ice Cream is sponsored by Premier Protein. As always, all opinions and recipe are my own.
Thanks so much for supporting the brands that support Runnin Srilankan!
Let me get real nosey today and ask you when was the last time you had yourself some oatmeal? Or, maybe, some overnight oats?
And…what did you put in it?
Did you, maybe, put some milk in it? And…maybe, some cinnamon? How about some sort of sweetener? And…did you happen to throw in something crunchy – just to shake up the texture?
Well…what if…we shook up the quantities of those ingredients…
And….ended up having…Oatmeal ICE CREAM for breakfast?! 😆
Yup – THAT is what happened at our home!
Now – I cannot take full credit for this ice cream. Last week, while on our second trip to Ample Hills Creamery in New York, my daughter and I got to sample their Nonna D’s Oatmeal Lace Ice Cream, which is basically brown sugar and cinnamon flavored ice cream with oatmeal lace cookies in it. Seeing I harbor an unconditional love for all things oatey, I got back to Atlanta and couldn’t get this ice cream out of my head!

Seeing it might be a year before we go back, I figured I would try my hand at making a tad bit healthier version of it so I could keep my tastebuds happy. I started off with some full fat coconut milk and a few splashes (actually a half cup) of Premier Protein‘s Vanilla shake in a blender. I added in some cinnamon, some brown sugar and vanilla before blending everything together. I stirred in some quick cooking oats and a chopped up, honey crunch Premier Protein bar, and let it the freezer do it’s magic.
While this Cinnamon Oatmeal Ice Cream is not an exact replica of Nonna D’s Oatmeal Lace Ice Cream, it is super tasty, and, it is packed with Premier Protein – AND OATS! Which kinda makes it suitable for breakfast – right?
Enter Below for a chance to win Premier Protein
a Rafflecopter giveaway

Ingredients
- 1 can full fat coconut milk
- 1/2 cup Premier Protein Vanilla Shake
- 1/2 cup Brown Sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 2 teaspoons cinnamon if you are not crazy about cinnamon, then only add 1 teaspoon
- 2 tablespoons Quick Cooking Oats
- 1 Honey Caramel Premier Protein Bar - cut up into small pieces
Instructions
- Add coconut milk, Vanilla Premier Protein shake, brown sugar, cinnamon, and vanilla and blend well
- Stir in Quick Cooking Oats and Honey Caramel Premier Protein Bar
- Pour into a chilled tray and freeze for an hour, take out and stir up with a fork. I repeated this about 3 more times before digging into this.
Cinnamon protein ice cream?! This is a thing?! You are a creative genius. I’m already swooning and immediately searching my pantry for some of that protein. Looks so so SO GOOD!!
No.freaking.WAY. I had plane Jane oats this morning with a little bit of applesauce, almond butter, and maple syrup, but I’d take this over my bowl any day! You never cease to amaze me with your creativity, Shashi! Another epic recipe 😀
I am all about dessert for breakfast and I give you two thumbs up for healthy oatmeal ice cream for breakfast! Love that this doesn’t require an ice cream maker, too!
This looks like a giant bowl of oatmeal cookie! In ice cream form. YUMMM
This is such a unique idea! I’m always looking for more ice cream recipes!
i have been having overnight oats every day lately…but let’s be real oatmeal ICE CREAM would be so much better! Amazing!
Oh yumm!! Love this! Its an ice cream and it is healthy. Can it get any more better?! So good.. Cant wait to try this.. Thanks for sharing Sashi!! 🙂
When I saw the headline, I knew this is going to be delicious! Great job Shashi! Can’t wait to try it! So creative!
Wow that is so creative!! And you could do something like sprinkle some toasted steel cut oats on top too 😀 Love it!
This ice cream sounds delicious!! I love that you added cinnamon and oatmeal flavors to it!
this is so clever! i never thought of that before. I haven’t made overnight oats in a while, so sign me up for the ice cream version!
Haha – You bet! Thanks Lindsay!
This is really clever Shashi. The internet is overrun with no churn ice creams at the moment. THIS is a stand out. Sharing!
Nagi – you made my day! I am so honored! Thanks so much!
the peanut butter caramel bar sounds really good!
It sure is! Good Luck! 🙂
All you have to say is cinnamon and I’m game!
Yay 4 cinnamon! 🙂
Cinnamon oatmeal ice cream? Wow! Is that for real? What an awesome idea. Oatmeal and cinnamon sounds amazing! I can have this breakfast everyday! 🙂
Haha – I like how you think Anu! I was having a little everyday and today I ran out! Gotta double the quantities next time! BTW – Thanks so much!
Why hasn’t anyone ever told me about oatmeal ice cream before??!!! Love the idea — such a fun recipe. Thanks!
Thanks KR – It’s more fun to eat 🙂